"CONFESSIONS OF A SHOPAHOLIC: A
STORY OF OUR
NATION"
by
Terrence Daryl
Shulman ________________________________
How did we get here? I mean, in this
money mess? Individuals, families, companies,
cities, states, countries--all in distress over
debt and financial mismanagement. Yes, there's
been greed. Yes, there's been fraud. Yes, there's
been costly wars. Yes, there's been delusions that
we could keep spending and borrowing like there's
no tomorrow. But how did we really get to this
point? And have we really even hit rock
bottom yet? A national
retailers' study recently estimated that 2009 will
see a less than 1% drop in overall sales compared
to 2008. Is this good news or bad news?
Only time will tell.
Ahoy! We may
have reached a watershed moment. It's
a new year with a new president and a new
course of action and, look out: after a several
month delay, the motion picture "Confessions
of a Shopaholic" is slated for
release on February 13th--just prior
to Valentine's Day!
Part silly
romp, part cautionary tale, "Confessions of a
Shopaholic" was a best-selling book first,
published in 2001 and written by Sophie Kinsella.
Ms. Kinsella has gone on to publish a series of
books featuring her "shopaholic" protagonist
Rebecca Bloomwood: "Shopaholic Takes Manhattan,"
"Shopaholic Ties The Knot," Shopaholic &
Baby," and "Shopaholic & Sister," as well as
other books with titles such as "Prada, Pumps and
Babypuder." Babypuder? Shameless, I
know. And while the
"Shopaholic" stories take place in London, their
themes are universal. Aren't they?
I
have a confession of my own: I just finished
reading "Confessions of a Shopaholic"--not because
I wanted to. I'd been getting phone calls from
various newspaper and magazine reporters over
the last month, each wishing to tie in the movie's
release to the growing awareness of the problem of
compulsive shopping as well as to the larger
economic woes of our nation and the globe. So, I
needed to bone-up on the storyline. And I'm going
to the movie the moment it comes out--again, not
because I want to. Call it my "civic
duty" of sorts. I work in the field of
compulsive shopping education and treatment. You
gotta keep up with pop culture.
Another
confession: I expected to hate the book--I'd
already pre-judged it as fluffy, nutritionless,
"chick-lit." I was surprised. I saw the appeal.
(Could a thousand positive reviews on
Amazon be wrong?) Ms. Kinsella is a skilled
writer. She's descriptive and knows how
to blend humor with pathos, cajoling
reader to feel disgust and sympathy
(or empathy?) toward her heroine
simultaneously. Thus, I found myself laughing
out loud more than several times as I read page
after page of our young British shopaholic's
attempts to keep herself in denial about her
shopping and spending while going to extraordinary
lengths to weasel her way out of her mounting
debt.
Becky Bloomwood is as much of
an icon as Carrie Bradshaw from "Sex and The City"
(I admit, I'm a fan of that show). She's
clever and pitiful at once
as she corresponds with her banks and
credit card companies throughout the book, citing
excuses for non-payment of her debt: "I broke my
leg," "my dog died," I have glandular disease,"
etc. And it's not far-off fiction when she
receives replies in the form
of both legal threats and
invitations to increase her credit limit and to
take out bigger loans. These passages, especially,
highlight the many mixed messages our culture
gives us. Spend! But don't overspend! Finding that
line between the two, apparently, is not so easy
for hockey moms or corporate
giants.
Mid-way through the book, it
hit me: this is satire! I have no idea if
this is what Ms. Kinsella intended but that's the
only way I could finish the book: to read the
hyperbole and drama--with a teaspoon of sugar--as
a portrait of our individual and collective
insanity of consumerism, affluenza, and
conspicuous consumption. I haven't read any other
of Ms. Kinsella's books and it is quite possible
I'm in denial and her best-sellers are nothing
more than a shameless exploitation of the
hyper-consumerist fantasies that many harbor deep
inside. Sure, there's more serious books and
movies out there on the topic of overshopping and
debt, but just as books and film often glamorize
boozing, drugging, gambling, sex addiction,
gluttony; it's our responsibility to read between
the lines and recognize and heed the danger
points.
I was disappointed
"Confessions of a Shopaholic" glossed over any
deeper exploration of the more
personal origins of the Becky's shopping
problem other than the few stereotypical
references to her mother's propensity to engage in
similar behavior. Further, Becky made no real
attempt to seek help (therapy, support groups,
meds, opening up to others); instead, she merely
tries to "white knuckle it." There is a trite
truism when she finds a more fulfilling job
which temporarily halts her habit. But, assumedly,
Becky's shopaholism is what defines her and
endears her to the millions of readers who follow
her story in the numerous sequels. One wonders: if
Becky got well, then what? Would her life be as
interesting, quirky? Think Carrie Bradshaw married
with children!
The novel
has a way of having us believe that Becky's the
only shopaholic in London. We know by fact and
instinct that isn't true. Is her "disease" her own
problem or does society share some blame? There's
currently a debate about whether to include
compulsive shopping or compulsive buying in the
soon-to-be updated DSM-V (Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual)--the bible of psychological
diagnoses. Some have argued for this and
others have argued that compulsive shopping and
spending are more cultural and social phenomena
than individual or widespread
dysfunctions. Some point to the relative absence
of shopaholism in poor countries. Perhaps this is
due to lack of access to money, credit and goods.
There's no doubt that access to stores, casinos,
food, alcohol, drugs, etc. increase the likelihood
of abuse and addiction. Societal norms also play
their part. But I've counseled shopaholics from
Manhattan to Boise (from Chanel to Shabby-Chic)
and all points in between.
For
those still concerned that the book--and soon
the movie--do a disservice to the seriousness of
compulsive shopping and spending, I don't share
that fear. If anything, in the time
between the release of the book in 2001 and the
release of the movie in 2009 I feel we have moved
forward in our sensitivity and understanding of
this problem through the likes of Suze Orman,
Oprah, Dave Ramsey, and many others.
We're also in the midst of the worst economic
crisis in history and "greed and conspicuous
consumption" are on their way out and, again,
maybe the movie can be treated like a vestige
of mindset past. Or
not.
With the recent meltdown of our
economy and economies around the word, many of
us--whether we've been overspending or not--are
looking anew at our relationships to money, credit
and things and re-evaluating our budgets and
priorities. I know my wife and I have already made
some choices--some easier, some harder--to cut
costs and save more. I've canceled my Sunday New
York Times, my HBO, my Time magazine, and tried to
reduce my business expenses; my wife has cancelled
her ballet classes, cut-back on chiropractic
care and massages, and some food favorites.
Together, we've been watching our driving and our
utility bills and put on hold a trip to Italy.
It's no fun doing without but it's also brought us
together and made us more appreciative of what we
do have.
Meanwhile, we continue to see how
old habits die hard in the headlines. Despite the
record governmental bailouts of banks and
investment firms after years (decades!) of living
high on the hog, news leaks out of continued
extravagances such as fancy retreats, executive
bonuses, and eyes on big purchases like private
jets. As country singer John Rich sings in one of
his new songs: "Yeah, while
they're living it up on Wall Street in that New
York City town/Here in the real world, they're
shuttin' Detroit down."
America,
it's time to get our soul back. As President Obama
declared in his August 2008 acceptance speech in
Denver: "Enough is enough!"
I will be
curious to see if the film version of the book
will adopt the same light-hearted, cheeky tone of
its forerunner or if, given the "movement" of the
last 8 years, the serious side of excessive
shopping and spending will be more emphasized. In
either event, it's an auspicious time,
indeed, for this movie to appear and, if nothing
more, it will hopefully spark discussion
in the media and in living rooms across America
and the world. "Confessions of a Shopaholic" may
just help us see more starkly where
we've been and who we've been and taste the bitter
and sobering medicine of it all. Or
not.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FEBRUARY: CELEBRATING BLACK
HISTORY MONTH: We acknowledge the painful and
triumphant history of the countless
African-Americans who help make up our country.
What a momentous and historic time we live in to
see Barack Obama elected president. Whatever your
political persuasion, let us recognize this as a
sign of great progress in moving toward better
race relations and as an inspiration to all that
anything is possible with hard work and a vision
of unity and brotherhood for all. May the promise
of equality and peace be
fulfilled. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FEBRUARY 14th--St. VALENTINE'S
DAY: An
affirmation: "I am my most
important valentine. I continue to learn to
love myself so I may also learn to love others
more
fully."
_________________________________________________________________________________________
WE APPRECIATE YOUR
SUPPORT! ________________________________________________________________________________________
|