"CONFESSIONS OF A SHOPAHOLIC"
The Movie
Review
by
Terrence Daryl
Shulman ________________________________
With much anticipation, I saw the
recently released movie "Confessions of a
Shopaholic"--twice, actually--during its first
weekend out. The various media reviews of the film
have been mixed--from dismal to several "3 stars
out of 4 stars"--including in The Detroit Free
Press, my local paper. Of course, reviewing movies
can be a pretty subjective endeavor.
From
an entertainment standpoint, I was pleasantly
surprised that the film was engaging, well-acted,
funny, and had a pace that rarely let up. Even the
music was well-placed. Mind you, I was not
expecting a serious docudrama about compulsive
shopping or spending and neither should you. I
viewed the movie as I read the book: as satire and
farce. However, I was encouraged to see that the
film made the attempt to highlight the main
character--Becky Bloomwood's--problem in a way
which was serious at times: her stress over her
debt, her lying and losing the trust of her
boss/love interest as well as her best friend, the
hoarded and cluttered rooms and closets, and her
denial and constant dodging of dealing with both
her shopping behavior as well as her underlying
issues. Remember, however, you'll see Becky
fret and you'll see her hair mussed up a bit, but
she never stops looking great even when down in
the dumps!
There's a pivotal comic scene
where hoards of women go bonkers over an impromptu
garment "sample sale," tussling among themselves,
and resulting in a throw-down showdown between
Becky and another woman over a pair of red
boots--I couldn't help but think eerily about the
Wal-Mart greeter who was trampled to death in New
York at the annual day-after-Thanksgiving
"shop-frenzy." It's a taste of what a drug addict
or any addict goes through.
As Becky
Bloomwood states in the movie: "All I know is
that when I shop, the world seems better. And
then, the feeling goes away. And I shop to feel
better again." A client recently told me she
related to that. Becky Bloomwood tried to
white-knuckle her abstinence, watched a video of a
anti-shopping guru, and eventually attended local
Shopaholics Anonymous groups in Manhattan which,
thankfully, even included men! Gradually, she
begins to realize the extent of her problem and I
can only hope some of us will see ourselves in her
despite the Hollywood happy ending. Oops, sorry if
I ruined it for you.
Speaking of happy
endings, it warmed the cockles to see
Becky actually come clean, use her talents, pay
off her debts ($16,000 through a one day fashion
fire sale!), connect with her untapped
passions--in love and in work--and regain an ounce
or two of integrity in her life. She becomes
the wholer, the wiser, and learns that shopping
and things don't ultimately buy happiness.
Perhaps the most moving moment for me was
when she's talking to her Dad who offers to sell
his recently purchase motor home after a lifetime
of savings to help bail Becky out of her $16,000
debt. Becky turns to him and says: "don't even
think of it, Dad, that motor home completely
defines you." Without missing a beat, her Dad--a
doofus played brilliantly by John Goodman--utters
the only intelligent line he's given: "Nothing
defines me except you and your
mother."
Now, back to that
Hollywood happy ending, though. Don't
think Becky will live "happily ever after"
without temptations or setbacks. Even at the
film's end as she's embracing her beau, Luke
Brandon, she offers a wink toward a store window
mannequin who winks right back at her. In one of
the more clever devices in the movie, the
mannequins wink at her, talk to her, gesture
toward her, beckon her. And, ironically, they even
begin applauding her as she finally resists
temptation. But, again, for how long?
And,
likewise, with all the buzz in the media over the
last month in highlighting and exploring the topic
of compulsive shopping and spending, one wonders?
For how long? For how long will the media be
interested? And as for the many millions of
Americans who are forced to confront their
tightening financial belts, one wonders: for how
long? Will better times come again and lead us
into complacency and bad habits again?
And
what about the sequel to the film? After all,
Sophie Kinsella has made a cottage industry of her
"shopaholic" books. Only time will tell. Let me
know when the book/movie "Confessions of a
Shoplifter" comes out!
GRADE: 3 out of 4
Stars
Note: I was pleasantly
surprised to see at the very end credits of the
movie the line "Shopaholics Anonymous Courtesy of
The Shulman Center." Someone from the film had
contacted me last summer asking permission to use
the name "Shopaholics Anonymous" for the support
group name in the film. I had no real rights to
grant permission but signed a faxed form anyway,
asking sheepishly for a credit at the film's end
when it was released. Lo and
behold!
_________________________________________________________________________________________
MICHAEL
PHELPS AND THE ENDLESS PURSUIT OF
PERFECTION. On the heels of the
"Confessions of a Shopaholic" movie with all its
emphasis on image and looking good comes Olympic
Gold Medalist and Everyman Michael Phelps' recent
fall from grace for being photographed smoking
marijuana at a recent party in South Carolina.
Now, whatever you think of his actions--much ado
about nothing to despicable--and whatever you
feel about the ensuing media frenzy and his lost
endorsements--despicable to "he got what he
deserved"--I'd hope most of us could agree that
this constant pressure and demand we keep creating
for "perfect performances" and "blemishless
behavior" does more harm than good to us
as individuals and to our society as a
whole.
Of course, we don't want to
throw the baby out with the bathwater: we
(naturally?) push ourselves as humans to our
new edges, improving and evolving to
discover what was previously thought to be
impossible. But this is different from striving
for perfection. Didn't Martha Stewart teach us
anything? Nobody really likes a perfect person
anyway and, as they say: pride goeth before the
fall. And, certainly, we bend (naturally?)
toward justice, benefiting from laws and standards
which also call for consequences when such are
broken. But in this increasingly un-private global
world we live in, one's every mistake (whether
you're famous or not) can be broadcast around the
world in a nanosecond. And any failing is a total
failing. Is this fair? It just is what it
is.
Now, this isn't Michael Phelps's first
black mark. He was arrested and charged with drunk
driving a few years ago--apparently that didn't
stop him from being placed on a pedestal. One can
only imagine if he had been arrested for
shoplifting--long ago or more recently--if that
would have looked "worse" than a DUI or a toke of
pot. In any case, perhaps it's ultimately a
blessing that he fell from grace. It's our
humanity that makes us, well, human. My only fear
for him--and for us all--is if we keep chasing
perfection and, after having fallen, chase it even
more--we're likely to get more of the same.
The relentless pursuit of perfection is
something I'm intimately familiar with. My own
shoplifting addiction grew largely out of my
striving to be perfectly selfless, giving,
independent, self-sufficient. I ended up acting
out the exact opposite behavior--taking,
stealing--as a counter-balance. I also see this
issue come up all the time in the recovering
addicts I work with. I see it run in my family
and, at times, in my friends.
I was
visiting my brother and my 7-year old nephew over
the weekend. My nephew had a "staging" of action
figures (wrestlers, zombies, aliens, superheroes)
assembled on a low table in the living room. I got
up to get something from the kitchen and
accidentally bumped the table's corner with my
leg. My nephew's 'diorama" was disturbed, an
action figure fell. He jumped up as if he'd been
stabbed. He snarled at me: "you knocked over my
wrestlers!" I said: "oh, I'm sorry, I didn't
realize it." He then began frantically trying to
put the figure back in its exact place it was
before only to knock over another figure and then
another figure--like dominos! He began crying and
flailing about helpless and grief-stricken. I just
observed in amazement. Of course, I saw myself in
him. Wow, I thought, at such a young age--already
trained somehow to demand perfect order. I let him
cry, offering just a few kind words: "It's okay.
I'm sorry." Thankfully, he eventually let go of
his attachment to perfection and enjoyed watching
the rest of a zombie movie with me.
I'm
thinking today of The Detroit Pistons--my local
professional basketball team--who just lost their
8th game in a row and have dropped to below .500
for the first time this late in the season since
2001. Why? Perhaps because they were not content
with being just an excellent team the last several
years which made the conference Finals but
couldn't get over the hump. So, they fired their
coach and hired a new one and, several months ago,
they traded their star guard Chauncey "Mr.
Big Shot" Billups to Denver for Allen "A.I."
Iverson. The trade, obviously, has been a
disaster. The team chemistry is ruined. I bet they
wish they would have just kept the team in place.
But, no, in this day and age nobody is content
with 2nd or 3rd place; it's win it all or you're a
loser. Sports just provide a more clear metaphor
for our larger values.
So, Mr. Phelps, I
wish you and all of us well as we proceed in our
lives trying to be the best we can be but maybe,
just maybe, taking a little of the pressure off
and keeping things truly in perspective. It's so
easy to forget this, isn't
it?
_________________________________________________________________________________________
CORPORATE GREED/EXCESS & THE
BAILOUTS: ARE WE ENABLING? IS THERE NO SHAME?
I don't pretend to be
an expert on economic or governmental affairs but
I periodically feel a knot in my stomach when I
continue to hear the dollar figures of
billions--or even trillions--lost over the last
sad chapter of capitalism gone awry. Almost all
the bigger companies--from the banks, to
investment firms, to the automakers, and
beyond--appear to have been living in a bubble. As
so, assumedly, have we--or at least most of us. So
much greed, so much fraud, so much pressure to
make "more, more, more" at any cost. So much
denial. So much financial immaturity and
mismanagement. And now, we the taxpayers, are
going to be footing most of the bill. Perhaps, we
need to look at ourselves, too, in how we also
played a part in this. Over the past two to three
decades, we've been overspending and chasing "The
American Dream" with reckless
abandon--individually and collectively. The bubble
was bound to pop. We're now hitting the proverbial
bottom.
Still, I feel sickened by
bailing out companies who have engaged in greed,
fraud, mismanagement, etc. and feeling held
hostage that if we don't bail them out we will all
suffer more. Talk about a "shit sandwich"--pardon
my French. What also bothers me is that many of
these corporate big wigs continue to spend "our"
money like there's no tomorrow--fancy retreats,
corporate jets, wining/dining and other
extravagant purchases. Have they no shame?
Apparently, very little. Something has gone wildly
wrong in our culture.
Whatever your
political persuasion, I am certainly rooting for
our economy to turn around and believe government
plays a crucial role in guiding this. But I also
believe that each one of us has to do some serious
soul-searching into our own attitudes, values and
behaviors--particularly when it comes to money,
things, credit and debt. Hopefully, change is on
the way. But as they also say: "Let it begin with
me."
________________________________________________________________________________________
U.S. ESTIMATES INDICATE THAT THEFT
CRIMES HAVE INCREASED 40% over the last two
months of 2009 due to the downturn in the economy.
Even Canada has suffered economically over the
last year or so and has suffered an
increase in shoplifting and employee theft
and other theft crimes. Also, in Canada, credit
card delinquencies have risen 10% in the last
year, bankruptcies have risen 50% since December
2008, and the jobless rate is 7.2%--the worst in
more than 30 years.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MARCH: I'd like to
honor my mother on her 70th Birthday on March
17th. My wife and I will be traveling to Florida
to visit her. She has been an inspiration to me
and has always supported me personally and
professionally. _________________________________________________________________________________________
WE APPRECIATE YOUR
SUPPORT! ________________________________________________________________________________________
|